'Shan' Hackett had been educated at
During the autumn of 1942 it had been decided to form a parachute brigade in the Middle East for operations, initially, in the eastern
Early in 1943 the Brigade, less the embryo 11th Parachute Bn to be formed from volunteers of PAIFORCE, moved to
Hard training took place in the rocky hills of Northern Palestine, and with the support of the Texan airmen, an enterprising series of parachute exercises were conducted in
It was inevitable therefore that the 4th Brigade soon took on much of his own character, especially in its independence of thought and deed; and it must be said, in its carefree approach to dress regulations, (but not 156 Parachute Bn under its Grenadier CO and RSM), an attitude which seemed to worry the hierarchy at HQ 1st Airborne Division recently arrived in Tunisia from the UK.
Although a relative newcomer to the airborne world (it was only 3 years old anyway!) it was his operational experience, combined with a free ranging intellect that gave him a wider concept of the potential employment of airborne troops, and the tactics that they should use. The
In Tunisia in the summer of '43 after the Sicily campaign, the 4th Parachute Brigade was tasked to carry out the first airborne operation in Italy which was to be at Salerno, until this was taken on by the Americans, (but with little success). Instead, the brigade was told to plan for several operations across the Straits of Messina, which Shan dismissed as 'mere puddle hopping operations'. He then submitted a carefully planned proposal to drop his brigade, in several groups, into the area across
The 4th Brigade eventually landed by sea from RN and USN cruisers at
He had trained his unit commanders to operate on their own initiative, but under his general direction, and when specific orders were needed they were brief and personal; for instance he told one of his staff " .... motor up to your battalion, give Colonel Dickie my compliments, and invite him to take Mottola" - a village perched high on a hilltop some 2 miles ahead. Shortly afterwards, he went forward to his other battalion, which was attacking Castellaneta, where Maj. Gen Hopkinson, commander 1st Airborne Division, joined him. "Keep your head down", Shan warned him , "there are snipers around", but the general in his red beret put his head over the wall. He was shot and died there.
The Brigade, with the rest of the 1st Airborne Division, returned to
He was as frustrated as his men, and he also became increasingly critical of some of the proposed operations. The new Allied Airborne Army had outstripped in size the capability of its senior Army and Air Force commanders to appreciate properly its effective employment. In early September orders were given for Operation Comet, an operation to carry out the same objectives as the subsequent Market Garden, but using the 1st Airborne Division and the Polish Brigade only. He commented later on the plans “…we (meaning Sosabowski, the Polish brigade commander, and himself) had both fought Germans before, and knew all about that. Apparently the airborne planners did not. Their plans to put down an airborne division were impeccable. What would happen after that was beyond them. They were to me like cooks who prepare a superb dish, and then add salt and pepper to taste. They prepared a superb deployment, and then added a few Germans. I shall always recall the deep disbelief in Sosabowski's voice; 'but the Germans, General, the Germans…..’. Happily this ghastly plan was, like the earlier ones, cancelled at the last moment".
For Roy Urquhart, he had the highest regard, and after the battle wrote of him ".... he was a splendid battlefield commander - the best fighting general I have ever served under, a great, imperturbable fighting Scot."
Unfortunately, for Operation Market Garden carried out seven days later, the senior airborne planners not only disregarded the inevitable swift German reaction, but also failed to deploy the British and American airborne divisions, so that they stood a reasonable chance of achieving their objectives rapidly.
So, as he foretold, his 4th Parachute Brigade, which he had raised, trained and led for nearly two years was cut to pieces in less than two days. There were so few survivors after the battle that the brigade was never rebuilt, but was amalgamated with a similar number of survivors of the 1st Parachute Brigade. As he himself said "I had raised this formation in the Middle East, taken it into battle in
After the war the family spirit that he had instilled into his brigade has lived on among the members that remain to this day. The old comrades of most of the units have thriving Associations and meet regularly. His officers have dined together each year since the war, and Brigadier Shan has been absent only for the last two years due to his ill health. On these and on other occasions, such as on the annual
After his brief but dramatic time in command of 4th Parachute Brigade he did not return to an active command in Airborne Forces in peacetime. It would be interesting to speculate that, if he had been appointed to command the 16th Parachute Brigade Group in 1954, rather than the 20th Armoured Brigade, that he might have been able to set our post-war Airborne Forces on to a more enlightened course, in keeping with their true potential, as opposed to the regular infantry lines which they have been forced to follow. He was, however, Honorary Colonel of the 10th Bn The Parachute Regt (TA) from '65 - '73, of which he was very proud, and as before he took a close personal interest in all its members and their well being. He was DCGS in the Ministry of Defence at the time when the Government made drastic cuts in the Territorial Army. Under the original plan, which had already been drafted into a White Paper, the 44th Parachute Brigade (TA) was to be disbanded, with only one parachute battalion remaining. He fought not only the military 'establishment' but also the politicians, and forced them to reconsider the decision; the brigade was saved (but only for another 10 years) but lost one of its four battalions and some supporting units. From these cuts he was able to increase the strength of the two TA SAS regiments.
He has also been as much loved by the Dutch people of the Oosterbeek area, not only by the family who cared for him behind enemy lines, but also by the many people that he has met and made his friends since those days. He has valued their friendship above most others. Whilst the events in 1944/45 were tragic for him, and for the Dutch people, nevertheless they forged a deep bond of friendship between the airborne veterans and the Dutch of all ages. These words of his sum up this feeling:
"This was a battle but its significance as an event in human experience transcends the military. The tactical, technical and logistic problems it raised are often of high and absorbing interest. More and more, however, those of us who fought through this battle have become aware that what remains with us can best be described as a spiritual experience. To see Dutch children who were not born when all this happened; most of whose parents were not born either, laying their flowers year after year on the quiet graves in the Airborne cemetery at Oosterbeek teaches a lesson not easily forgotten".
See also John Waddy’s article on Shan Hackett at